More fields for Lean-to

[ERYpTION]

Would it be possible to add a couple of fields to the 'More Fields' option when editing a Lean-To (a Shelter-type)?

Where I live operators of Lean-tos often recommend doing a reservation and sometimes require paying a small fee for use. Therefore it would be useful with easy access to adding this information with the Fee and Reservation fields. They are currently missing for Lean-tos.

Thanks.

[mnalis]

I could be wrong, but I think you should request that at id-tagging-schema which Every Door uses for tagging presets.

Particularly, a change to https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/main/data/presets/amenity/shelter/lean_to.json adding moreFields of fee, like e.g. done for verterinary.

In fact, as it is relatively simple change of JOSN (text) file, you may even want to try doing a PR yourself there? It's relatively easy (fork the repository, and click on edit button, and when you've done your change if it looks OK click on "create pull request" when it pops out).

Or of course you can simply open the issue there and wait for someone to pick it up. Feel free to mention that issue URL here, so interested parties can find it more easily (and perhaps help)

[ERYpTION]

Here in Denmark about 2/3 of the lean-tos on public land can actually be booked in advance and for the privately owned (but publicly available) lean-tos I think it is about the same. Many of the privately owned lean-tos also require a small fee. So even though a tag is rarely used (reservation=yes/required) the actual situation can be different in some areas.

[tordans]

FYI, we added some guidelines to the id-tagging-schema so have a shared understanding on what to add and how to get there https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/main/GUIDELINES.md

Usage numbers are one factor. Relevant usage in apps or something like this is another. – See the Link for more.

[mnalis]

So @tordans if I understand correctly, that "🏝️ Local Presets and Fields" would imply it would be OK to modify shelter_type=lean_to to only have fee=* field in Denmark (and Sweden)?

It says "presets and fields can be given a local filter" so it seems to be possible; but searching for "filter" does not give any more matches...
I'm aware whole preset can be made per-country (via locationSet as in e.g. moped_link-NL.json, but how can only some field in the preset be limited to a country, could you point me to example or docs? If so, I'll try making a PR for this.

[mnalis]

I seem to have found example at presets/highway/crossing.json which references @templates/crossing/markings.json which references fields/crossing/markings-DE-AT-CH.json which seems to has locationSet which is hopefully applied for that field only. Seems somewhat complex, but I can try to play with it...

Update: Apparently, locationSet can also be used directly on the field? https://github.com/ideditor/schema-builder#locationset-1. See also discussion here: ideditor/schema-builder#94 (comment) and fields/royal_cypher-GB.json + presets/amenity/post_box.json as an another (simpler) example

[mnalis]

• ref. Ask for fee=* and reservation=* on shelter_type=lean_to (only) in Denmark (and Sweden) openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema#1350